MOSHÉ, MANJU, QUEEN & I
2014 threw up three pleasant surprises —
entertaining films that tell credible stories of women. That such films are
rare is a result of gender politics, not economics
By Anna MM Vetticad
Winter is a time for bonfires, boots and smart overcoats. It’s also the season for a parade of best-of-the-year-gone-by lists from film critics. But I want to share with you a more personal compilation — three pleasant surprises for a cinephile forever in search of entertaining films that tell credible stories of women.
Queen:
Watching a mainstream Bollywood film which makes me go “oh my god, that could be me” is a rare experience. Queen was that kind of film. The story of a conservative middle-class Delhi girl (Kangna Ranaut) who rediscovers herself after her fiancé dumps her shortly before their wedding, it reminded me of how starved we women are of films about us.
Watching a mainstream Bollywood film which makes me go “oh my god, that could be me” is a rare experience. Queen was that kind of film. The story of a conservative middle-class Delhi girl (Kangna Ranaut) who rediscovers herself after her fiancé dumps her shortly before their wedding, it reminded me of how starved we women are of films about us.
The US and India, home to the world’s largest film industries, are guilty on
this front in different ways, governed by gender politics that drives
economics. Here in India, film industry power structures are so male-dominated,
that despite a steady trickle of women executives in production houses and the
occasional woman director or writer, films remain largely dictated by the male
gaze.
Result: most tell stories of men and are told from a male point of view, even
if women have substantial roles in them. It is also generally assumed that
women-focused films need to be about a dispiriting ‘issue’ because someone
somewhere thinks women do not have amusing, uplifting experiences.
In this scenario, Queen was
path-breaking in many ways. It was about a woman whose existence in the film
was not dependent on her relationship with a dominant hero, and it was highly
entertaining. Director Vikas Bahl shared the writing credits with Parveez
Shaikh, Chaitally Parmar, Anvita Dutt and lead actor Kangna Ranaut herself —
reminding us that sometimes all it takes to make a warm, fun film about a woman
is a sensitive man who asks women what they want and who they are.
How Old Are You:
Director Rosshan Andrrews’ How Old Are You marked Malayalam actress Manju Warrier’s return to films after a decade and a half. It turned out to be startlingly courageous. Think about it: how often does a mainstream Indian heroine ask her on-screen husband whether he would have wanted her to emigrate with him to a foreign country if servants there were inexpensive?
Warrier plays a woman who subordinated her career ambitions in favour of a
boring job that would allow her to focus entirely on her husband and daughter,
only to become the object of their disdain because of her limited interests and
achievements. In an industry that tends to retire lead actresses at a
relatively early age or relegate them to supporting roles, it was unusual to
see an actress in her late 30s playing the heroine in a film positioned as
commercial, not ‘art cinema’. For the record, Queen and How Old Are You
were money-spinners, proving once again that audiences are far more open-minded
than gendered film industries give them credit for.
Les Stances a Sophie:
Indian film buffs would perhaps best know Israel’s Moshé Mizrahi as the Oscar-winning director of Madame Rosa (1977). He made his debut in 1971 with the French film Les Stances a Sophie (Sophie’s Ways), which was lost to the world for nearly four decades thereafter because the producer went bankrupt and most prints were seized.
And then the Embassy of Israel called earlier this month. They were screening Sophie’s Ways in Delhi. Would I moderate
a discussion with the octogenarian director?
Sophie’s Ways is about a young woman
in 1970 Paris who does not believe in being tied down to one man, but
impulsively succumbs to a marriage proposal early in the film. As she becomes
frustrated with the relationship, Moshé delivers an incredibly progressive,
grim yet humorous take on women’s sexuality and sexual freedom.
The film had a limited release in France back then but got a lukewarm response,
according to Moshé, “because the women’s liberation movement had not yet come
into the French media in a big way as it had in America by then, so French
people thought the film was too much.” In 2008, a digitally restored version was
released on DVD. Six years later at the Delhi screening, I asked myself for the
millionth time: what prevents film industries from making more such mainstream,
women-centric films?
“Economics” is the standard answer. The truth lies elsewhere. In India’s male-dominated
industries, for instance, mainstream heroes are perennially cast in lead roles
with larger-than-life personas. Mainstream heroines are rarely offered such
films. Over time, this creates a disparity in numbers and obsessiveness between
fans of male and female stars. This usually ensures that the occasional
commercial, woman-centric film — which is rarely marketed as heavily as
hero-oriented films — doesn’t get the same opening collections that a
hero-centric film does, and is more dependent on word of mouth. “We told you
so,” producers promptly say.
But hey, you created the system, and you work hard to
perpetuate it. Films like Queen and How Old Are You (and the Priyanka
Chopra-starrer Mary Kom, for that
matter) have been hits despite these constraints. Make such
films in large numbers over a period of time, create equitable circumstances
for heroes and heroines, and then see how many more of these you get. It’s a
crying shame that in the 21st century, film buffs like me are making such lists
of pleasant surprises
(Anna MM Vetticad is the author of
The Adventures of an Intrepid Film Critic. Twitter: @annavetticad)
(This column by Anna MM Vetticad was first published in The
Hindu Businessline newspaper on November 29, 2014)
Photographs
courtesy:
(1) Still
from Queen – Everymedia PR
(3) Still from Les Stances a Sophie – Embassy
of Israel
Note: These
photographs did not run with the column in The
Hindu Businessline
