Friday, July 18, 2014

REVIEW 276: PIZZA (3D)


Release date:
July 18, 2014
Director:
Akshay Akkineni
Cast:




Language:
Akshay Oberoi, Parvathy Omanakuttan, Dipannita Sharma, Arunoday Singh, Rajesh Sharma, Omkar Das Manikpuri, D. Santhosh, Hussain Dalal
Hindi


Pizza is terrifying. There you go – you don’t have to get to the last paragraph to discover the bottomline of this review. Debutant director Akshay Akkineni’s 3D supernatural thriller Pizza – a psychological thriller if you wish to see it that way – is terrifying. 

This is a Hindi remake of the Tamil film of the same name released in 2012. The original was directed by Karthik Subbaraj, and starred Vijay Sethupathy and Remya Nambeesan in roles played here by Akshay Oberoi and Parvathy Omanakuttan. This latest version is what the retelling of a well-told story should be: the screenplay remains pretty much the same, yet there are enough changes in the treatment to improve upon the strong foundation laid by Subbaraj.

Pizza begins with Kunal (Oberoi) waking up from a nightmare. He’s one of those people who doesn’t ‘believe’ in ghosts, yet like everyone who does not, somewhere deep down inside he actually does. Is there a human being out there who can escape a fear of the unknown?

Kunal is a pizza delivery boy who lives with his wife Nikita (Omanakuttan), an aspiring writer of ghost stories. They lead a rather normal life with all the regular problems that young urban couples have. An unplanned pregnancy briefly disrupts the peace at home, since Kunal worries about how they will bring up a child on their modest income, but that quarrel too is quickly resolved. Then one day he visits the home of his boss whose wife, it turns out, is possessed by the spirit of someone called Anjali. And life is never the same again.

How that turn of events leads Kunal to a haunted bungalow is something I will leave you to discover when you watch this excellent spook story, the best to emerge from Bollywood since Ram Gopal Varma made Bhoot in 2003. In the months and years that followed the success of Bhoot, there were many that tried desperately to clone the chills. What they did instead was trot out tons of clichés ranging from ear-splitting, screechy sound effects to women with hair falling over glazed eyes, humans flying through the air, litres of blood and goo, and ominous, mantra-chanting holy men of all faiths. It was hard not to be exasperated, amused and/or disappointed by them all, including Varma’s own lifeless Bhoot Returns in 2012.

The best horror films don’t allow viewers to feel conscious of how they are being manipulated. Just a handful of Mumbai directors – Vikram Bhatt among them – have hit the nail on the head, and just occasionally at that, in this genre in the past decade. While one has to admit that the bar is not high in Bollywood, it’s not fair to judge Akkineni by that: he pole-vaults a mile above it.  

The selling point of the original Pizza was the number of twists in the tale in the second half. Its weakness was that the scares in the first half, while genuine, were too few and far between. When the hero was trapped in that haunted house, there were too many long patches of inaction between the patches of frightening action. The Hindi remake plugs that loophole so thoroughly that it makes Kunal’s time in the bungalow its USP – an extended sequence of unrelenting, heart-stopping, thankfully low-on-gore, gasp-inducing jolts that I confess had me cowering in my seat.

The second half does not manage to sustain the pace of panic, but the job has been done by then. Besides, there’s at least one very neat twist coming up; and much else to like, such as the fact that it feels like a slice of real life in terms of its settings, costumes and the manner in which relationships play out. In the interactions between Kunal and Nikita, especially their tensions over their unborn baby, it also shows that a film does not have to be preachy or “about a social issue” to deliver social commentary.

Sound design is crucial to a horror flick. This one has so much audio clarity that you can clearly distinguish between Kunal’s footsteps on a wooden floor and on a carpet in a deserted corridor. Tapas Nayak is the man behind this delightful detailing. Pizza also uses interesting graphics for its opening credits. The 3D is a worthwhile add-on. And the music, though not as splendid as Santhosh Narayanan’s background score for the Tamil film, is goosebump-inducing all the same.  

The screenplay is backed by a cast that is good even if not as solid as the stars of the Tamil film. Akshay Oberoi is effective but does not have the acting depth of Vijay Sethupathy. Arunoday Singh, who hit the nail on the head with his performances in Aisha (2010) and Yeh Saali Zindagi (2011), is the weak link here, the only one whose appearances in the scary scenes border on the farcical – unlike the others, he looks like that naughty elder brother or cousin who waits around the corner to scare kids with rolling eyes and a loud “bowww”. Omanakuttan’s so-far untapped range is evident here. And Rajesh Sharma as the superstitious pizzeria owner is sturdy as always.

If you haven’t seen the original film then I’d strongly suggest that you avoid it and its plot synopsis on the Internet until you’ve seen this one. I held off watching the Tamil Pizza until I’d seen the Hindi remake this week. No doubt my response to this film would have been different if I’d done things the other way round. No doubt too, my response to the original would have been different if I’d seen it first. Goes without saying that each of us reacts uniquely to every film we watch depending on the sum total of our life’s experiences, our tastes and where we are at that point in time. Be warned: one of my fellow critics at the press preview of Pizza was highly amused at those of us who were petrified by the proceedings on screen. Me? I was scared witless in the first half of Pizza. The second half slows down, but it still had me hooked.

Rating (out of five stars): ***1/2

CBFC Rating (India):

A
Running time:
117 minutes

Poster and trailer courtesy: UTV Spotboy

Friday, July 11, 2014

SELF CENSORSHIP IN THE INDIAN FILM INDUSTRY / FILM FATALE: COLUMN PULISHED IN THE HINDU BUSINESSLINE


(This column by Anna M.M. Vetticad was first published in The Hindu Businessline on July 5, 2014)

Headline: THE NATURE OF DISSENT

Introline: If freedom of expression must include the right to offend, it must also include the right to protest. But should it be at the cost of “self-banning” in films, art, academia?


She: “Why didn’t you tell me you were in the Sinhala Army?... My two brothers were killed by the Army. My parents brought me here so that I wouldn’t get raped by someone like you…”

He: “I didn’t ask if your brothers were terrorists. I didn’t ask anything about you. I didn’t tell you anything about myself, because it doesn’t matter any more.”

She: “It matters to me. My brothers were not terrorists. They were innocent schoolboys.”

He: “I didn’t kill your brothers. I was doing a job. Then I quit.”

Was it this conversation between a married couple in Sri Lankan director Prasanna Vithanage’s With You, Without You that irked unnamed groups in Tamil Nadu? We do not know. What we do know is that the critically acclaimed Sinhalese-Tamil film — a cutting critique of the impact of war on ordinary people — was withdrawn from theatres in Chennai this fortnight, after threatening calls from persons claiming to represent Tamil interests.

The protests were bizarre considering that With You, Without You leans almost entirely towards its female protagonist who is a Sri Lankan Tamil. A representative of the film’s Indian distributor, PVR Director’s Rare, confirms that the Chennai police refused to provide security to theatres screening it and advised them to withdraw it. A letter from co-producer Rahul Roy and others to Chief Minister J Jayalalithaa has received no response as this column goes to press.

This, of course, is now a familiar scenario — the collusion between opponents of free speech, the police and politicians who side with them either actively or through calculated silence. The message from the establishment is clear: some subjects are best avoided. The result has been what Bollywood director Shoojit Sircar describes as increased “self-banning”. Last year, Sircar’s Madras Café starring John Abraham was not released in Tamil Nadu despite being cleared by the Central Board of Film Certification. Theatre owners were just too scared after Tamil nationalist groups claimed it demeaned the struggles of Sri Lankan Tamils.

On the contrary, Madras Café was a telling commentary on the futility of war. The “self-banning” didn’t start with its release though. It began at the writing stage. The film is a fictionalised account of India’s intelligence-gathering efforts and covert operations involving the LTTE in the years leading up to former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi’s assassination. Recent history is such a hot potato in this country though, that LTTE is called LTF in the film; and Rajiv’s character is not called Rajiv, he is addressed throughout as just “ex-PM”.

Stage two of the “self-banning” happened when Sircar showed his script around in 2006-07. Actors and producers were unwilling to touch it. “The first actor I approached for John Abraham’s role said the subject is too sensitive,” recalls the director who ultimately shelved the project till the end of the Lankan civil war in 2009.

Let’s be clear here: this is not a column against protests. If freedom of expression must include the right to offend, it must also include the right to protest. Liberals in India are so disgusted with the repeated calls for bans on artistic and academic works — often for mindless reasons — by political or social organisations with a history of violence, that anger has become a reflex reaction to all protest.

Protest, in fact, is invaluable because it generates debate. This column is a protest. Reviews skewering books and films are a protest against their quality or the positions they take. When reports emerged in 2005 that the Eye Bank Association of India and the All India Ophthalmic Society had filed PILs against the Urmila Matondkar-starrer Naina — the story of a woman who gets a corneal transplant and is possessed by the spirit of the donor — many of us laughed. I confess I did. Yet, reactions from the doctors drew attention to the fact that superstitions and misinformation are the reasons why many Indians don’t donate their organs, or accept transplants.

Our opposition then can’t be to protest, but to enemies of a diversity of opinions, and to implicit or explicit threats of violence. Do read that again please: implicit or explicit threats of violence. When Dinanath Batra of the Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti sends legal notices to publishing houses, he is within his rights to do so. Yet, two major publishers while capitulating to his demands in the past year, have done so publicly citing a fear of violence. Batra may not have made open threats to either of them, but the track record of organisations he is affiliated to and the open support he has from the Vishwa Hindu Parishad are enough to get any ordinary citizen worried.

In the absence of protection from the State, most then feel compelled to give in. In a nation of raw nerves, there can be no greater threat to art, academia and a free press.

(Anna MM Vetticad is the author of The Adventures of an Intrepid Film Critic. Twitter: @annavetticad) 

Photograph courtesy: PVR Director’s Rare

REVIEW 275: HUMPTY SHARMA KI DULHANIA

Release date:
July 11, 2014
Director:
Shashank Khaitan
Cast:


Language:
Alia Bhatt, Varun Dhawan, Sahil Vaid, Gaurav Pandey, Ashutosh Rana, Siddharth Shukla
Hindi


Humpty Sharma ki Dulhania (HSKD) is DDLJ revisited, packaged in fake liberalism. “Ja Simran, ja jee le apni zindagi (Go Simran, go live your life),” said the despotic father played by Amrish Puri to his adult daughter while granting her permission to marry the man she loves in Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge. That iconic dialogue from the regressive 1995 blockbuster is repeated in HSKD when another despot (Ashutosh Rana) grants permission to a boy to marry his adult daughter. It’s irrelevant that Kavya Pratap Singh (Alia Bhatt) and Rakesh/Humpty Sharma (Varun Dhawan) are in love and want to marry. What matters is that Daddy says it’s okay.

HSKD seems designed as a tribute to DDLJ, with the addition of a pretence at progressiveness. And so, Kavya is given two attributes that Bollywood seems to consider essential characteristics of a forward-thinking woman: she has sex before marriage and she drinks alcohol. You see, in Bollywood’s book, if a woman does both the above she has provided proof of being cool. Conversely, should we assume that they consider women uncool if they exercise their freedom to make informed choices not to have sex before marriage or not to consume alcohol?

This is what happens when closet conservatives feign open-mindedness. They forget that true liberalism is about letting men and women exercise choices, instead of demanding that they fit into moulds prescribed by the Left or the Right. They also end up revealing their true colours through characters like Kavya who out-drinks Humpty and consummates their relationship before taking any pheras, but will not marry him without Daddy’s clearance, even if Daddy is a louse who bullies the women in his family, taunts a daughter for being divorced, repeatedly hits Humpty and his friends, and gets them bashed up. Like society, the entertainment media often projects women as a prize to be won by men, but it still makes the skin crawl when an educated girl like Kavya is so passive that she barges up to Humpty even as he is being tested by her father, and asks: Kya tumhe mujhe jeetna hai ki nahin (Do you or do you not want to win me)?

I’m not saying women like Kavya don’t exist; I’m saying, please don’t position her as a liberal creature (or a “modern” ladki, which is what Humpty calls her at one point in the film).

As stories go, HSKD is light-hearted fun to begin with, before it gets repetitive and predictable in the second half. With just weeks to go for her wedding, Ambala girl Kavya escapes from home on the pretext of buying a Rs 5 lakh designer lehnga in Delhi. There she meets Humpty, the no-good son of a stationery shop owner, and his two loyal friends Shaunti (Gaurav Pandey) and Poplu (Sahil Vaid). Kavya and Humpty click immediately. He helps her friend out of a tough spot, while going to great lengths to help Kavya raise the money for her shaadi ke kapde.

That lehnga mission is treated so seriously by the film, that you’d think he was feeding starving slum kids or clothing street dwellers. As we know will happen from the very first frame of the film, boy and girl fall in love. Then boy and girl have sex. And girl promptly takes off to Ambala to marry Daddy’s chosen groom. In case you think those were spoilers, let me assure you they are not. There’s not a single moment in this film, not one, where I sat up in wonderment or shock or surprise and thought: oh my, now there’s something I’ve not seen in a Hindi film before!

The film’s soundtrack – often noisy and generic – includes love songs, shaadi songs in which the entire mega-clan gathers to sing and dance, and in the end, a club number with the closing credits. In short, most elements in the formula are dutifully covered.

Creative laziness shows up elsewhere too when the story forgets Kavya’s fiancé Angad (Siddharth Shukla) in the end. Where did he go? No idea. And in the guise of coolth, what is this mindless film doing encouraging women to put themselves in dangerous situations? In one scene that seems highly improbable for India, Kavya, who barely knows Humpty at that point, joins him and his guy friends at his shop for a late-night drinking session, then casually decides to spend the night there with them. This is the opposite end of the spectrum from victim blaming in sexual violence. What next? A film encouraging old people not to get servant verifications done?

While the going’s good, Varun and Alia are their usual sweet selves though it needs to be said that he must now steer clear of that child-like way in which he sometimes rolls his R’s, and she should grow past her occasional baby-girl tone. The two Student of the Year co-stars may not have sparks flying between them, but they share a pleasant warmth. Rana, Pandey and Vaid are interesting inclusions in the cast. So is TV’s hot bod Shukla who is making his film debut here.

Now if only the screenplay had an iota of originality, heft or thought. Even when it is purportedly delivering harmless fun, its humourisation of the leads’ amorality is troubling. I mean, we’re meant to be charmed when Humpty breaks into a teacher’s house, hangs him from a tree and demands to be given pass marks; while Kavya, the teacher’s niece, agrees to take money in exchange for ensuring that he does get those marks. Again, I’m not saying these things don’t happen; just that the manner in which the film cutesifies these situations is rather unthinking.

This is disappointing because Dharma Productions has come up with some pleasant surprises in its smaller rom coms such as Wake Up Sid, Ek Main Aur Ekk Tu and this year’s Hasee Toh Phasee. Even Dostana, beneath its veneer of frivolity, had some pathbreaking moments such as when a traditional Indian maa is shown accepting her beta’s homosexuality. What then explains the superficiality and absolute lack of meat in Humpty Sharma ki Dulhania? HSKD is really funny in places, but it’s so insubstantial, unimaginative and regressive that that’s just not enough.

Rating (out of five stars): **

CBFC Rating (India):

U/A
Running time:
135 minutes
Poster courtesy: Everymedia PR