Release date:
|
August 23, 2013
|
Director:
|
Shoojit Sircar
|
Cast:
Language:
|
John Abraham, Nargis
Fakhri, Siddhartha Basu, Raashi Khanna, Prakash Belawadi, Ajay Ratnam, Piyush
Pandey, Avijit Dutt, Dibang
Hindi, Tamil, English
|
If
you are looking for John Abraham taking off his shirt in a political thriller
infused with song and dance, if you are keen on decibel levels raised to
needlessly over-dramatise intrinsically melodramatic situations, then this is
not the film for you. Madras Café is
what D-Day might have been if Nikhil
Advani had reined himself in just that little bit. This is a fictionalised account
of Indian intelligence-gathering and other covert operations involving the LTTE (called LTF in the film) in the couple of years
running up to the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi (called “ex-PM” here) and
centred around an imagined RAW operative Vikram Singh
(John).
Santosh
Sivan’s The Terrorist and Mani
Ratnam’s Kannathil Muthamittal are
perhaps the foremost Indian films to have covered the LTTE so far. Both were
lovely but different from this one, more emotional and novel-esque. Madras Café’s near-unflinching,
near-newspaper-like matter-of-factness is its strength. It goes quietly from
Point A to Point B to Point C the way real life does, underlining the
unrelenting, risky and thankless nature of the espionage agent’s work. It does this
without glamourising spies as Hollywod does. Vikram Singh is no James Bond, nor
Ethan Hunt from the MI series. He is
a real man with real vulnerabilities. He is brave but not without fear; he even
has nightmares when he returns from a war zone. He does not drink martinis “shaken
not stirred”; he’s just a human being who’s shaken and stirred. This then is Rajiv Gandhi’s assassination seen through
the eyes of Vikram. He doesn’t know
for sure that it will happen; we do. It is to director Shoojit Sircar’s credit
that the film remains compelling right till the end even though we all know what’s
coming.
Though
Madras Cafe is replete with
historical references and rich in detail right down to reminding us of the
tennis shoes Rajiv wore on that fateful day, it’s important to stress that it is
not a documentary. Blending fact with fiction in the manner it does is rarely-charted territory for Bollywood but Shoojit manages well. The film is based on
the premise that Rajiv was killed by a shadowy network involving Sri Lanka’s
Tamil Tigers and global forces opposed to the late Indian prime minister’s
efforts to find a peaceful political solution to the Lankan civil war. Now this
may bother you if you are not inclined to take such a kind view of Rajiv
especially since the film fails to mention the irony that Indira Gandhi’s and
Rajiv’s regimes had played a role in nurturing the nascent LTTE. So the key to
enjoying Madras Café is to accept
that history is always someone’s version of events. Let’s also be clear, this
film is not about Rajiv; he is merely
on the sidelines here, as Vikram doggedly goes about his business.
Shoojit
and Madras Café’s writers (story and
screenplay: Somnath Dey and Shubendu Bhattacharya, dialogues: Juhi Chaturvedi) rarely
abandon the tone of detachment in their narration. Some problems merit a
mention though: the flashback device used to tell us the story – Vikram Singh
recounting those years to a priest in a church – didn’t work for me and led to
some of the film’s very few less-than-true-to-life moments, including Vikram walking
into the camera quoting Tagore’s Gitanjali. There is also one awkward scene with
Vikram’s boss’ wife (played by Ruma Ghosh) in which she sheds tears over the ex-PM’s
assassination and asks: What was his fault? Nowhere else does Madras Café appear to deify Rajiv, which
makes this maudlin moment rather jarring, especially considering the tricky
political questions involved.
The casting
is unconventional. John surrenders his sex-bomb image to this role, and
delivers a convincing performance. It’s been a pleasure watching this man grow
as an actor in the past 10 years. His Vikram is surrounded by interesting actors playing well-written characters, each memorable despite
brief appearances: TV producer and 1980s telequiz host Siddhartha Basu as
Vikram’s boss Robin Dutt, model Raashi Khanna as Vikram’s wife Ruby, adman
Piyush Pandey as the Indian Cabinet Secretary, former Aaj Tak journalist Dibang
as an unnamed figure in Bangkok, among others. All the actors playing Tamil
militants are believable as is journalist-and-theatre-artiste Prakash Belawadi
in the role of troubled RAW honcho Bala. One sore point: Gayathri Devarajan in
a few-seconds-long appearance as Bala’s wife. Nargis Fakhri doesn’t particularly
enrich her role as London-based war correspondent Jaya Sahni and seems to have
been cast for her foreign accent, but to be fair to Shoojit, he does control
her bobbing head and pouting lips unlike Imtiaz Ali who directed her debut Hindi film Rockstar.
Kathryn
Bigelow’s Zero Dark Thirty comes to
mind in the context of Madras Café,
as does David Fincher’s Zodiac and several
other Hollywood crime and political dramas that have aimed at a near-documentary
feel. Indian film makers tend to avoid recent history and current events because
of our political class’ penchant for bowing to violence-prone religious and
political groups. That’s why in Madras
Café we get LTF’s Anna Bhaskaran (Ajay Ratnam) who just happens to bear a striking
facial resemblance to LTTE’s V. Prabhakaran. That’s why Rajiv Gandhi can’t be
called Rajiv Gandhi and we must suffer the strain of hearing character after
character refer to him as just “ex-PM” in a way you know real people would not.
That Madras Café has pulled off what
it has done despite these constraints is laudable.
John
in particular must be applauded for picking unusual projects as a producer (Vicky Donor – also directed by Shoojit –
was his first, this is his second). Kudos too to him for taking a strong stand
against those protesting the release of Madras
Cafe. I can imagine where the BJP’s opposition is coming from: either they
are pandering to extremist Tamil sentiments or, with just months to go for the
next general election, they’re uncomfortable with a film that takes a positive
view of a Congress leader. The ban demand by Tamil groups is inexplicable
though. Their complaint seems to be that LTTE has been portrayed as terrorists
in this film. Err… LTTE is shown assassinating a former Indian PM in this film.
You mean it did not?!
In
fact, the two primary takeaways from Madras
Café are: (a) innocent civilians are always the first to suffer in violent
conflict situations, and (b) “one man’s revolutionary is another man’s
terrorist.” Both are thoughts articulated by Vikram Singh who even refers to
Anna Bhaskaran as an “idealist” at one point. Elsewhere Dibang’s character
says: “Har kisi ka apna sach hota hai,
depends on where you are standing.” What more do LTTE sympathisers want?
Despite
some of its questionable politics, Madras
Café pulsates with life, a realistic feel and a sense of danger at every
turn. The locations are spectacular but DoP Kamaljeet Negi does not try merely
to overwhelm us with their beauty; with art director Vinod Kumar and music
director Shantanu Moitra as his co-conspirators, he uses his camera to build up
the atmosphere of the hazardous world inhabited by Vikram. As I sat watching
the film in that darkened hall, there was a point at which Vikram’s shoes
became my own, when I began to dread the perils dogging him. I can’t think of a
better compliment than that for Shoojit Sircar’s Madras Café.
Rating (out of five): ***1/2
CBFC Rating (India):
|
U/A
|
Running time:
|
2 hours 10 minutes
|
Photograph courtesy:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madras_Cafe
