Release date:
|
September 30, 2016
|
Director:
|
Neeraj Pandey
|
Cast:
Language: |
Sushant Singh
Rajput, Rajesh Sharma, Kumud Mishra, Anupam Kher, Kiara Advani, Disha
Patani, Bhoomika Chawla, Neeta Mohindra
Hindi
|
Hagiography or biography?
Creators of biopics often struggle to decide between the two. M.S. Dhoni: The Untold Story has
different problems.
In skirting the most questionable
aspects of cricketer Mahendra Singh Dhoni’s life, in sidestepping all
controversies involving him and the BCCI through his reign, and in avoiding any
mention of corruption in India’s sporting establishment, the film ends up
attributing its protagonist’s trials almost entirely to fate, personal finances
and heartbreak. The result: M.S. Dhoni is
so lacking in energy and verve for the most part, that you have to wonder
whether there is no mid-path between over-dramatisation and flatness.
Born in Ranchi to
lower middle-class parents, Dhoni – Mahi to family and cricket fans – has gone
on to become one of the game’s most successful players and team captains. It
goes without saying the journey to this place has not been easy. It never is,
not in any arena, not even if you are the child of a millionaire in a country
that lays out the red carpet for sporting talent. In Mahi’s case, there are the
added burdens of economically humble beginnings and the fact that India can be
hell for anyone who wants to make a career on a sports field.
Our celluloid
Mahi’s concerns are far more mundane. A government office fails to forward a
letter in time, he misses a flight, a member of a selection committee tries to
push someone else’s name over his for no apparent reason – while all these
could well be possible, and that unforwarded letter is believable, the film
fails to effectively convey the blood, sweat, tears and toil that must have
gone into making Mahi the icon he is today.
Writer-director Neeraj Pandey’s latest work suffers primarily from his seeming
determination to play it safe. Making Dhoni out to be an apolitical, all-round
nice guy would have been a compulsion since the film is co-produced by the cricketer’s long-time friend and business associate Arun Pandey. Presenting a
sanitised view of the BCCI and flitting over serious internal issues must have
been necessary too since Dhoni is still in active sports and would obviously
not want to offend his bosses with a film he has backed to the hilt through its
promotions.
But what the
bejeezus prompted the
muting of even Virender Sehwag’s name at a selection committee meeting? Was
this a Censor Board decision or a choice made by the filmmaker? The producer’s
rep has not yet responded to an email query on this point, but even if the
muting was sought by the Censors, it fits in with the overall, ultra-careful
tone of the narrative.
M.S. Dhoni: The Untold Story stars Sushant
Singh Rajput as one of cricket’s brightest living stars. It begins with Mahi
preparing to take the field at the 2011 Cricket World Cup. Before going deep into the game, it rewinds to a
hospital on the day of Mahi’s birth and then follows his story in a linear
fashion until it returns to 2011.
In the first half,
the film does a
good job of capturing the intimacy and sweetness of social interactions in
small-town Ranchi, the warmth in Mahi’s pocket-sized home and the dreariness of life as a ticket inspector for a man
whose dream is to play cricket, in contrast to his middle-class Indian father’s
ultimate dream of a government job for his son. When Mahi lifts off in
international cricket though, M.S. Dhoni dips.
With diplomacy
being the storyteller’s main concern, post-interval it almost feels as if
Mahi’s career milestones are being mechanically checked off a list. At this
point, the film starts getting repetitive. Cricket match on. Enter: stressed
out father (Anupam Kher) watching TV, mother at prayer in the room’s pooja corner, sister (Bhoomika Chawla)
and brother-in-law cheering before a television in their home, tense mentors
watching separately in their respective homes, friends watching at a shop.
These scenes are amusing at first, but after a point and even when the parties
get together, serve no purpose other than to add to the film’s inordinate
length of 190 minutes along with numerous scenes of real-life matches into
which Rajput is inserted.
The actor gets
Mahi’s demeanour and a cricketer’s body language right. We already know he is
capable of that from his fantastic film debut in Kai Po Che. After the exit of child star Zeeshan who plays a junior Mahi,
Rajput also metamorphoses brilliantly from a physically slight youngster to a
strapping adult over time in M.S. Dhoni,
a result of excellent teamwork between him and the make-up, styling and camera
departments. He is interesting too when playing happy, flirtatious or
mischievous. In moments of sorrow and anxiety though, he falls short.
This inadequacy
becomes particularly glaring when he shares screen space with the two stand-out
members of the film’s impressive supporting cast: Rajesh Sharma and Kumud
Mishra playing Mahi’s first coach and his first patron respectively.
Their junior by
many years, young Kiara Advani steals the show from right under Rajput’s nose
when she enters the picture as Mahi’s girlfriend Sakshi who becomes his wife.
It would be unfair though to judge Rajput by
M.S. Dhoni. He was electric
in Kai Po Che and deserves the
benefit of the doubt in a film that ends up as an insipid PR exercise for the real Mahi.
The writing is occasionally even
unthinking. At the hospital where Mahi is born, there is confusion over whether
Pan Singh Dhoni’s wife gave birth to a girl or boy. In another country this
could have been an acceptable moment of mirth about a nurse’s inefficiency. In
boy-obsessed India and its sub-set – boy-obsessed Bihar – where male infants
are sometimes stolen from hospitals, you wonder if a point is being made, and
then realise that it is not. This is one among several superfluous scenes in
the film.
I also did not
understand the need to fictionalise Sakshi as being a complete stranger to Mahi
when even a non-cricket fan like me has read that they were schoolmates. And why do we not get to see
interactions between Mahi and cricketing legends Sourav Ganguly, Sachin
Tendulkar and Virender Sehwag beyond file footage of matches? Yuvraj Singh
(played by a well-cast and well-styled Harry Tangri) gets some space, but only
very little.
Whatever.
Through M.S.
Dhoni, there are flashes of
humour and pleasant touches that show us what might have been if Pandey had not
been constrained. My favourite moment is in the treatment of a friendly
Pakistani gentleman who allows Mahi the use of his phone, without drums beating
to announce his nationality and tackily link it to his goodness. He is there
not as a harbinger of cross-border amity or discord as we see in most Hindi films, but as a regular
person. I also enjoyed the way the film quietly addresses
the challenge of being an ordinary young woman in a conservative society
romantically linked to one of the country’s most famous men.
Overall though, the
screenplay lacks insights and depth. M.S. Dhoni: The Untold Story starts off well but
does not seem to know where to go from there.
If Neeraj Pandey needed to be
this careful, perhaps he should have manufactured a bottle of antiseptic instead of
making a film.
Rating
(out of five): **1/4
CBFC Rating (India):
|
U
|
Running time:
|
190 minutes
|
A
version of this review has also been published on Firstpost:
Anna ma'am,
ReplyDeleteVirender Sehwag was dropped from the team in 2013. The teleconference shown in the film takes place prior to an Australian series in 2008 and the three players whom Dhoni asks the selectors to drop(and the mention of whose names is muted) are Sourav Ganguly, Rahul Dravid and VVS Laxman; so it isn't the mention of Sehwag's name that is muted!
Dhoni is famous for his impish behaviour at times and his distinctive inability to express emotions of sorrow and anxiety. Anyone who has watched Dhoni since the start of his career will tell you that. His countenance during the press meet after the 2011 WC win was indistinguishable from that after the Indian team's subsequent 8-0 defeat to England and Australia. So, not only did Sushant NOT fall short in moments of sorrow and anxiety, he actually aced as Dhoni in those scenes! The one thing that I thought during those scenes was, 'This might as well be Dhoni himself, trying very hard to emote, but unable to go beyond a poker face!'
Hi Deepu,
DeleteMy reference is not to a muting of words spoken by Dhoni during that meeting. I’m referring to one name (not three) brought up by a selector seated to the right of the table when the camera is on him and it is possible to lip-read that name. As I mention in my review, right after watching the film I sent an e-mail query to a representative of one of the producers about this instance of muting – since I have not received a response either confirming or denying it, I can only conclude that I saw right.
Regarding your observations about Sushant Singh Rajput’s acting, I am afraid you have taken me very literally. I did not at all mean that his face should have been more mobile during the scenes in which Dhoni experiences sorrow and anxiety. I am well aware of Captain Cool’s famed stoicism. A character who tends to be inexpressive is obviously hard to play, and I felt that Rajput’s expressions of that inexpressiveness were effective only with certain emotions. I think he was marvellous in Kai Po Che, he managed to make an impression even in a small role in PK and in films that did not fare well at the box office. Perhaps my expectations were too high. Either way, he worked only partly for me in this film. Let us agree to disagree on this point ☺
The news that Sakshi and Dhoni was school friends is false.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.hindustantimes.com/cricket/the-truth-about-sakshi-and-dhoni/story-8FrJbW54UrhSGy1pxg4FYP.html
read this
Hi.
DeleteThanks for the link. I trust that you have clicked on the link I too have provided in the review.
You would have noticed that I have chosen my words carefully in this matter: I wrote that I have “read that they were schoolmates” – since this is what I remembered most widely reported at the time of their wedding – because I cannot and will not claim to be an expert on the personal lives of celebrities I do not know closely. This is also why I made it a point to hyperlink within my text to an article from a major mainstream media publication (The Times of India) about this subject. Here it is again for your benefit – it says Sakshi “studied with Dhoni in DAV Shyamali school in Ranchi”:
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Know-all-about-Dhonis-better-half-Sakshi/articleshow/6129318.cms
Do note that even the Hindustan Times article you have posted here gives a description that is vastly different from the way their first meeting is portrayed in the film. If Sakshi was a friend of Mahi’s manager who was also one of his closest friends, as the article says, it is hard to believe that she had not at least heard Mahi’s name from him – even if she was completely disinterested in cricket, newspapers, TV, hoardings etc etc and had therefore not heard of him from elsewhere. The film shows that Sakshi was clueless about Mahi’s existence when they first met.
Considering that this business of them being schoolmates was so extensively reported at the time of their marriage and considering that M.S. Dhoni: The Untold Story spends considerable time on their romance, I would imagine it would have made sense for the film to show either Sakshi or Mahi mentioning that the press was misreporting this, if indeed it is an instance of misreporting.
In the absence of such a clarification, I am afraid I have gone by the available information.
Thanks for taking the trouble to write to me though.
Regards,
Yes. Sakshi not knowing dhoni is quite unbelivable in the movie. Hindustan article is true since I have seen an interview with Dhoni where he speaks how they met which is same as the hindustan article, also how he proposes is same as in the movie.
ReplyDeleteOh, but how can you say the HT article and the film are both correct? The HT article does not match the film's portrayal of their first meeting.
DeleteAnyway, as I said, since it has been widely reported that Sakshi and Mahi were schoolmates and since the film spends so much time on his romances, I do wish this point had been woven in too if, as you say, most reports are incorrect.